Roundup is popular herbicide sold in hardware stores throughout North America. It’s also used extensively in the agricultural industry. It’s made by agrichemical giant Monsanto. However, it has a dirty secret.
Sheppard, who ran a coffee farm in Hawaii, used Roundup for years one of more than 800 cancer patients currently suing Monsanto. That’s because researchers have found that glyphosate, the main ingredient in Roundup, is “probably carcinogenic to humans”.
Sheppard and other plaintiffs argue that Monsanto never warned consumers about the risk of cancer and covered up studies that confirmed the correlation between their products and disease.
The World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer first labeled glyphosate as “probably carcinogenic to humans” in March 2015. Specifically, the report stated, “The evidence in humans is from studies of exposures, mostly agricultural, in the USA, Canada, and Sweden published since 2001. In addition, there is convincing evidence that glyphosate also can cause cancer in laboratory animals.” (2)
That was the tipping point that got the plaintiffs their day in court.
Taking Monsanto to Court
Timothy Litzenburg is the lawyer currently representing more than 500 of the plaintiffs. He argues that most of them didn’t know of the possible link between Roundup and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma until the report came out.
So why aren’t other companies that use glyphosate being sued?
Litzburg explains: “This is an oversimplistic answer, but Monsanto invented/discovered it, they held the patent for many years, they are the EPA registrant for glyphosate, and they continue to dominate the market. Furthermore, we are not alleging that our clients got cancer from glyphosate alone. We are suing because our clients got cancer from Roundup. … Roundup contains animal fats and other ingredients that increase the carcinogenicity of the glyphosate. Glyphosate alone is carcinogenic, but the addition of a surfactant has a ‘synergistic’ effect.”
Monsanto, of course, continues to deny the connection between glyphosate and cancer, stating “Glyphosate-based herbicides, including Roundup-brand formulated products with surfactants, all have a long history of safe use and do not pose any unreasonable risk to human health when used according to label directions.”
They insist that the IRAC’s report failed to “establish a link between glyphosate and an increase in cancer.” In their eyes, the lawsuits have no merit. Yet, they have gone above and beyond to defend their products.
William F. Heydens, a Monsanto executive, responded to the IARC’s report by sending an internal email to company toxicologist Donna Farmer with the subject line “RE: IARC planning”.
In the email, he suggested ghostwriting parts of an “overall plausibility paper” to save money. Also, he said a “less expensive/more palatable approach” could involve experts only for some of the less controversial parts of the report. Then, Monsanto would “ghost-write the Exposure Tox & Genetox sections.”
Trudo Lemmens, a University of Toronto professor who specializes in health law warns that ghostwriting is a common problem in studies and reviews because “It undermines the entire trust we have in the scientific basis of reports written by experts if we allow them to be ghostwritten and if scientists put their names on it.” For their part, Monsanto claims the email doesn’t prove anything and that “The paper and its conclusions are the work of the glyphosate expert panel. The paper also underwent (a) rigorous peer review process before it was published.”
To read the emails in question, click the links below:
- WILLIAM HEYDENS’ FEBRUARY 19, 2015 EMAIL(p. 220)
- WILLIAM HEYDENS ON ‘IARC FALLOUT’(p. 103)
- DAN JENKINS – “STRAIGHT TALK” FROM EPA OFFICIAL(p. 103)
- ” ‘IF I CAN KILL THIS I SHOULD GET A MEDAL’ “(p. 102)
- View the entire document withDocumentCloud
In the meantime, the plaintiffs continue to suffer from their illnesses and hope for justice. Sheppard and her husband had to sell their farm and make the move from Hawaii to California to get better access to cancer treatment.They’ve burned through their saving to pay her medical bills.
When Sheppard got too sick she and her husband had to sell their coffee farm and move from Hawaii to California to get better access to cancer treatment. They have also had to deplete her 401(k) to pay for medical bills.
As for her opinion on Monsanto, she says, “They didn’t take away my life, thank goodness, but they took away our dreams, our savings.”
- Sepsis Killed This Woman’s Father And Knowing These Signs May Have Saved Him
A nurse once said, “if you’re sick, don’t go to a hospital”. This may seem silly and contradictory but it’s …
- 10 Ways to Balance Your Hormones for Health, Energy and Weight Control
With so many known medical conditions out there, it can be hard to find out the root cause of our …
- Top 10 Natural Ways to Keep Your Brain Fit
Your brain—not to be confused with your mind—is one of the more vital organs in your body. Its health affects …
- Your Oral Health and Oil Pulling
Oil pulling is a centuries-old Ayurvedic practice of vigorously rinsing the mouth out with, you guessed it, oil. Practitioners say …
- Cancer Diagnosis Spurs 90-Year-Old Traveler To Take The Trip Of A Lifetime
Guts, grace, dignity, and humor—that’s how we all want to be remembered for after this life. Here’s the story of …
- This Spice Helps Protect Your Brain From Fluoride Poisoning
Fluoride is found in so many places that is it nearly impossible to avoid it. It can be found in …
- 17 Best Memory Tricks To Keep Your Mind Sharp At Any Age!
Memory techniques are a core part of your daily routine when you’re in school. You needed them to help learn …
- 14 Natural Antibiotics To Fight Infection, And What Drug Companies Don’t Want You To Know
14 of the best time-tested natural antibiotics used to kill bacteria and reverse life threatening infections. Antibiotics can be lifesavers: …
- Best Natural Herbs For Insomnia
Sleeplessness, or insomnia, is a condition I’m asked about over and over again. This isn’t really surprising when you think …
- 5 Ways to Treat Irritable Bowel Syndrome
IMAGINE HAVING A CONDITION with symptoms so severe that you can’t leave the house, yet your doctor calls it a …
- Children Are Being Prescribed Melatonin Unnecessarily…Bedtime Routines Are Just As Effective
“Unless a child has a diagnosed condition such as autism that has been scientifically proven to be helped by melatonin, …
- How to Do a Self Breast Exam At Home: Warning Signs of Breast Cancer to Watch Out For!
Doing a self breast exam every now and then can go a long way in preventing cancer growth. Breast cancer …
- If You Get Sinus Headaches or Constant Congestion You Need To Check For This Hidden Connection
Have you ever experienced a cold that just won’t quit? Even after symptoms of throat and chest pain subside, it …
- Some Cancers Heavily Dependent on Sugar to Grow, Study Finds
While studying the metabolisms of different types of cancer, researchers at the University of Texas in Dallas discovered that certain …
- This Almond and Kale Smoothie Contains All The Nutrients You Need For Stronger Bones
Osteoporosis is a common condition that develops as we age. The elements of bone begin to decay, making them brittle …