There are at least two sides to every story.
It is often pure subjectivity as to which you prefer to adhere.
When researching serious matters, we pore through evidence and try to be objective, yet the conclusions to which we arrive often are based on our position at the beginning of our quest.
A thinking person will at least consider all sides.
Our Story Begins in 2006
In 2006, Prince Charles embarked on a tour of India. One of the very troubling situations he found was an alarming number of suicides among farmers. He delved deeper and discovered a previously-unknown factor in these tragic deaths: many of the farmers who took their own lives had experienced the repeated failure of genetically-modified (GM) crops. He vowed to help by setting up the Bhumi Vardaan Foundation to provide aid and education to small farmers.
The story was taken up in 2008 by The Daily Mail, whose reporter travelled to India to see for himself. He reported that many of the suicides in the villages he visited were by men who–after planting GM cotton seeds that failed–were without money, in debt, and faced the loss of their lands.
Award-winning Indian rural affairs journalist Palagummi Sainath said at a lecture at the Institute of Development Studies in Kolkata:
“We have been undergoing the largest catastrophe of our independent history—the suicides of nearly a quarter of a million farmers since 1995. We are talking of the largest recorded rate of suicides in human history.”
The information we’re given is this: corporate-driven interests, sanctioned by the Indian government, aggressively market GM seeds and their accompanying pesticides/herbicides to cash-crop farmers (primarily cotton) beginning in 2002 with the promise of vastly higher yields.
The price for the seeds is 1000 times that of conventional seed. Farmers take out loans to buy the seeds, figuring they’ll make it all back and more with the higher yields. What they’re not told—among other things—is:
1) GM plants require twice as much water as conventional cotton
2) you can’t use seeds from the current year’s crop for planting the following year because of a built-in “terminator gene” that causes the plants to die after one season (this means, of course, that farmers have to buy more seeds)
3) prices for their harvests will not be relative to their investments and they will end up losing money because of governmental subsidies for cheaper products from the United Kingdom and United States
4) historically, GM seeds do not produce greater yields than non-GM seeds.
We all know statistics can be manipulated to support whatever your agenda.
Of course, there was a backlash of this report because it’s simply horrific. One of the biggest GM-seed manufacturers, Monsanto, denies any responsibility. It asserts that the GM cotton they sell grows great. (If given enough water, which is a critical issue for every farmer.) Media outlets call Prince Charles names, attacking his intelligence and knowledge of the issues. Various news agencies say it’s a myth and that The Daily Mail’s reporter’s views are skewed.
Then There’s the Data.
According to a report by the National Crime Records Bureau of the Indian Ministry of Home Affairs, the number of suicides in India has grown every year from 2000 to 2010. The total number of farmers in India has decreased during that time (as agribusiness takes on a greater share of the nation’s farming) while the relative number of suicides has increased among small farmers.
What Color is Your Lens?
There is obviously a bigger picture here, as there are an increasing number of suicides in India among the general population. The issues surrounding that (poverty, illness, financial insolvency, etc.) must be addressed. Where the role of genetic modification and farming practices comes in depends on the lens through which you view the data.
Should small farmers—most with limited education and wherewithal and zero political power—know to ask the seed salesperson for certified data from other farmers in the region, attesting to the claims of higher yields? Should they know to ask how much water was needed and the environments in which the very successful crops were grown? Should these subsistence farmers who depend on the harvesting of their crops for their very lives and those of their families be able to just avoid the temptation and pressure of the promises of a multi-national, multi-billion dollar company?
All crops—conventional, organic, GM—run the risk of failure due to any variety of reasons. Are these farmers unlucky and should they have planned for such failure as a contingency?
Maybe. But if GM farming is a part of the cause of such misery and destruction, it is one tragic factor that can be readily removed from the equation.
- 27 Weird Shaped Fruits And Vegetables That Will Still Give You Plenty of Nutrients
Food comes in all shapes and sizes. But despite how they look, these weirdly-shaped fruits and vegetables still offer plenty …
- Researchers Discover Link Between Cancer, Thyroid Disorders and Iodine Deficiency
A recent study discovered unusually high levels of a specific thyroid hormone, as well as thyroid peroxidase and thyroglobulin antibodies, …
- STOP Throwing Food Scraps Away! Here Are Some Exciting Ways to Boost Nutrition and Save Money
Do you feel guilty when throwing away food scraps while cooking? Try keeping those ‘scraps’ instead. This video shows you …
- 4 Ayurvedic Herbs That Help Support Healthy Blood Sugar Levels
Ayurvedic medicine practices date back to pre-Biblical times. Ayurvedic medicine prioritizes a holistic approach to healing, using plant-derived medicines, many …
- 5 Strawberry Recipes for The Beginning of Summer
Berry season is just around the corner, with ripe and juicy strawberries suddenly becoming available. Strawberries are delicious and nutritious, …
- 6 Surprising Facts You Need to Know Before Drinking This Popular Type of Tea
Does green tea have caffeine? The answer is yes. But before you snap your fingers and opt for a different …
- 5 Mouthwatering Miso Recipes
Miso comes with all of the health benefits of fermentation. This fermented soybean paste is full of enzymes that aid …
- Researchers Tested Dairy Cows From 8 Different Farms…Nobody Expected This!
Need another reason to ditch Round Up chemicals, including its main ingredient, glyphosate? If you’ve got milk, then more than …
- The 12 Best Natural Supplements For Managing Blood Sugar Levels
Struggling to get your blood sugar levels under control and manage your diabetes? It can be hard to deal with …
- Big Food Wants GMOs to Be Labeled as ‘Natural’
(originally written by Cookson Beecher) There was a time when food was food. You ate it and were glad of …
- 5 Healthy Recipes For Your Next BBQ
As summer approaches, everyone is excited about getting out their grills for barbecues and block parties. Unfortunately, the classics, such …
- Dr. Yoni Freedhoff And Food Marketing Liars
Dr. Yoni Freedhoff is a medical doctor and assistant professor at the University of Ottawa. He was invited to deliver a …
- Coca-Cola Attempts to Go Healthy With Stevia-Sweetened Coke Life
A healthy Coke. Ah, how sweet. Really. Coca-Cola, in an effort to recoup decreases in sales of the last several …
- Drinking This ONE Fruit Everyday Does Amazing Things For Your Arteries And Blood Pressure
Several studies have been done on the efficacy of pomegranate juice in reducing oxidative stress and improving overall heart health, …
- Top 5 Fitness Fueling Foods
Orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Kevin R. Stone, encourages his patients to dedicate themselves to their recovery by seeing themselves as an …