Last year, a bill was introduced in Congress to override individual states’ requirements for labeling food that contains genetically-modified organisms (GMO), imposing on states’ sovereignty and jurisdiction and ignoring their citizens’ opinions (votes) on the matter.
It’s been touted “Monsanto’s Dream Bill”.
The Bill, which has 37 co-sponsors, failed to pass in last year’s session and has been re-introduced to the current Congress. Called the Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2014, the Bill is worded to make us feel warm and fuzzy: the Act will require testing of GMO that will be used in food, manufacturers must notify the Secretary of Health and Human Services well in advance of plans to put the GMO on the market, and the Secretary is required to determine that the food product is as safe as the same product produced without the particular GMO. Then there is a clause that says that this Act will supersede any state legislation already passed regarding the particular GMO and any labeling requirements the state mandates.
The author of Bill HR4432 explains his reason for introducing it:
“We’ve got a number of states that are attempting to put together a patchwork quilt of food labeling requirements with respect to genetic modification of foods. That makes it enormously difficult to operate a food system. Some of the campaigns in some of these states aren’t really to inform consumers but rather aimed at scaring them. What this bill attempts to do is set a standard.”
Food labeling makes things difficult? If it costs more to have different labels for different states, then it seems simple enough to openly disclose all ingredients on every label. Or is that too simple? The essence of the Bill is to legislate convenience for giant food manufacturers to do whatever they please, regardless of what their consumers want.
Confusion is a lesser problem than intentional misrepresentation.
In addition to the changes to state labeling requirements, Bill 4432 allows GMO foods to be labeled “natural”. We can’t go down this path in this small article–it’s too egregious in and of itself. Here is what the Chief Marketing Officer of one natural foods manufacturer stated about this part of the law:
“The…bill would leave consumers even more confused, not less. Allowing genetically engineered ingredients to be included in the product’s label ‘natural’ will undermine consumers’ trust in the growing, vibrant natural products industry. This bill sends us backwards in terms of addressing consumer confusion.”
Does the federal government know better?
The debate continues around GMO foods and their safety for human consumption. Studies on both sides support their findings–it seems to depend on who is funding the research.
Let’s look at the federal government’s track record on substances that were later admitted to be detrimental to human health: saccharin, DES, DDT, triclosan, the pesticide Roundup, synthetic statins–the list is too long to cite. To summarize, the federal agencies that exist to protect our health have consistently fallen short.
Where does our power lie?
Oregon’s voters passed a ban on genetically engineered crops from being planted in their counties, despite Monsanto and other Big Ag spending half a million dollars to stop it.
Residents of Texas banned hydraulic fracturing (fracking). Hawai’i has limited the use of GMO crops. It is on the smaller local scale that individuals and grassroots organizations can make their voices heard. State and local governments were set up for that purpose.
There is no evidence that GMO enhances crop yield–quite the contrary, even by Monsanto’s admission. GMO are therefore not the “enormous boon to all of humanity” that the Bill’s author suggests.
In addition: in the last year, one of the U.S.’ largest corn importers, China, rejected GMO corn, causing a loss of almost half a billion dollars for corn farmers. Many countries are passing more stringent anti-GMO laws, not weaker ones.
There are many issues here to consider. Regardless of where you stand on the GMO issue, the impingement of states’ rights are at stake in this case. We work hard to do the best for our families. Our representative government was formed to enable the majority to make the rules. When the power to make our voices heard is rescinded, we have relinquished much more than the ability to decide which can of corn to buy.
- The Healthiest Ice Cream You’ll Ever Have – Turmeric And Coconut
Ice cream is one of the most popular desserts enjoyed in the United States. In the last few years, food …
- Top 3 Tips to Lower Your Risk of Breast Cancer
Many people consider cancer to be a scary possibility regardless of your lifestyle. Many people do all the “right” things …
- Marathon Runners Put Winning Aside To Honor World War II Veteran
“Thanks for your service,” utters one racer after the next as they stop in their tracks mid-race to give 95-year-old …
- Doctors Removed His Heart and Installed This Weird Device In Its Place. The Results are Shocking.
In March of 2011, a gentlemen by the name of Craig Lewis, a 55-year-old suffering from a life threatening heart …
- Why Magnesium is the Most Powerful Relaxation Mineral Known to Man
It can’t be stressed enough how necessary Magnesium is for a healthy and functioning body. Absence of this important nutrient …
- Onion Extract Can Help Lower Blood Sugar Levels, Study Shows
A recent study has researchers wondering if onion extract could be the key to new therapies for individuals with diabetes. …
- Losing Just 1 Gram of Fat In The Pancreas Will Have THIS Effect On Your Body
Losing a single gram of fat could be enough to reverse type 2 diabetes – as long as that fat …
- Simple Hack To RIPEN Any Rock-Hard AVOCADO In Just 10 Minutes
There’s a reason why avocados taste so good : it’s all in their healthy fats and incredible nutritional profile (1). …
- Stop Using Store-Bought Antiperspirants! They Make You SMELL Worse in The Long-Run?!
Sometimes, in attempting to “cure” a problem, the methods you use can result in a worsening of the problem you’re …
- Sleep Helps Flush Toxins From The Brain
A good night’s rest may clear your head – literally. For centuries, scientists and philosophers have wondered why people sleep and …
- How to ACCELERATE Toxin Removal By Stimulating Your Liver With These Commonly Ignored Herbs
Your liver really goes through a lot. As you go about your day, your body constantly comes into contact with …
- The American Sugar Consumption
Unless you’ve been living under a rock for the past decade, chances are you’ve heard or read something about sugar …
- This French Beekeeper Trained His Bees To Make Honey From Cannabis
Honey and cannabis are some of the most healing natural substances known to man. While one is available nearly all …
- The Dangers of Air Fresheners (Plus 10 Natural Options)
You’ve probably seen the commercial: A mom walks into a teenager’s room, takes a sniff and tells him no “nice” …
- High Intensity Exercise Helps Curb Appetite, Study Says
In a new study published in June this year, researchers at the University of Western Australia discovered that high intensity …